How the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact Would Change Campaigns
Meet two voters. Both are made up, but you know them.
Linda is a Republican in Fresno, California. Marcus is a Democrat in Lubbock, Texas. Both have voted in every presidential election since they turned eighteen. Not one presidential campaign has ever knocked on their doors, and none ever will. Their states are decided before the first ad airs.
Meanwhile, a retiree in suburban Milwaukee sees so many campaign ads every October that she mutes her TV until Thanksgiving.
That is how the Electoral College works in practice. It's not "one person, one vote." It's "one swing-state person, a lot of attention."
A plan to change this is closer to happening than most people realize. So let's think through what campaigns would actually look like if it worked.
Where the Compact Stands
The National Popular Vote Interstate Compact is an agreement among states to give their electoral votes to whoever wins the national popular vote. Here's the clever part: it only takes effect once the member states hold 270 electoral votes, enough to decide the election. Until then, it does nothing.
As of this spring, 19 jurisdictions with 222 electoral votes had signed on. Virginia was the most recent. Gov. Spanberger signed HB 965, pledging the state's 13 electoral votes to the national winner. That leaves the compact 48 votes short.
After last week's midterms, some coverage points to a plausible path through five states: Arizona, Michigan, Nevada, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin. Together they hold 61 electoral votes. Notice who's on that list. It's mostly the swing states, the places that benefit most from the current system. Asking them to join is a little like asking the popular kid to abolish recess.
Still, it's no longer a thought experiment. So what would change?
1. The Battleground Map Disappears
Today, campaigns spend almost all their money and time in a handful of closely divided states. Everyone else is a spectator.
Under a national popular vote, Linda's vote in Fresno counts exactly as much as a vote in Pittsburgh. So does Marcus's in Lubbock. There's no such thing as a "safe state" anymore, because states stop being the unit that matters. Votes are.
2. Running Up the Score Becomes a Strategy
Right now, winning California by 5 million votes is no better than winning it by one. Every vote past the winning margin is wasted, so campaigns don't bother.
Under a popular vote, those extra votes are the whole game. Expect huge turnout operations in places that campaigns now ignore: California, Texas, New York, and Florida. Expect Republicans to finally organize in rural parts of blue states, and Democrats in cities in red states. Tens of millions of people would become worth courting for the first time in their lives.
3. Ad Money Follows the Price of a Vote
Campaigns are businesses with a deadline. They'll ask a simple question: where can I buy a persuaded or mobilized voter most cheaply?
That probably means more national TV and digital ads, and less saturation bombing of Philadelphia and Milwaukee. The Milwaukee retiree gets her TV back.
But the money doesn't grow. Even supporters of the compact admit that no campaign could run in all 50 states at the per-person intensity of a recent battleground campaign. So attention would spread more evenly, and also more thinly. Fewer people would get a lot of attention. More people would get some.
4. The Message Changes, and Maybe Governing Too
Swing states have shaped what candidates talk about. Rust Belt manufacturing and Florida-specific issues get outsized airtime because the voters who care about them sit in pivotal states.
Under a popular vote, national themes would carry more weight. That could reach past campaigns and into governing. One analysis cites research finding that battleground states receive about 7 percent more presidentially controlled grants and twice as many disaster declarations. If swing states stop deciding elections, presidents lose some of the reason to favor them. A tornado in a safe state might start getting the same response as one in Ohio. It's a little embarrassing that this would be a change.
5. Close Elections Get Messier
Here's a real downside. Under the current system, a razor-thin result usually comes down to one state, like Florida in 2000. Under a popular vote, a razor-thin national margin could mean recount fights in dozens of states at once.
There's also no runoff in the compact. The winner is whoever gets the most votes, even if that's 38 percent. That gives third-party candidates and spoilers new kinds of influence, and campaigns would have to plan for them. That isn't a reason to reject the idea, but it is a reason to think about pairing it with something like ranked-choice voting.
6. The Lawyers Go First
Before any campaign adapts, the courts would weigh in. Critics argue the compact needs congressional approval, and one election law expert argues that states outside the compact would have a strong case in court. Until that's settled, campaigns might have to plan for two systems at once. Imagine a coach preparing for a game without knowing whether it's basketball or football.
The Big Fight: Would Cities Run Everything?
This is the objection you'll hear most, so let's take it seriously.
The critics' case. The Heritage Foundation argues that campaigns would focus on the same few zip codes, and that states with no big donors and no sprawling cities would be left out. Others say small, rural states would become permanently irrelevant.
The supporters' case. National Popular Vote points out that we already know how campaigns behave when every vote counts equally, because that's how they work inside each state. In a statewide race in Pennsylvania, campaigns don't write off rural voters to camp in Philadelphia. They go everywhere. Supporters also argue that small states are ignored today not because they're small, but because they aren't close. New Hampshire is small and gets plenty of attention. Wyoming is small and gets none.
Not so fast, everybody. The math gives each side a partial win.
Big metro areas do hold a lot of voters. But no metro area comes anywhere near a majority of the country, and neither do the ten biggest combined. A candidate who wrote off rural America would be throwing away tens of millions of votes. That's not a strategy. That's a concession speech.
Most political scientists expect campaigns to go where votes are cheapest to win or turn out. That isn't the downtown core, where one party already wins by huge margins. It's the suburbs and exurbs, the places that are genuinely mixed. Those places would probably matter even more than they do now. (For a careful academic version of the "it won't be a disaster" argument, see "A Not-So-Calamitous Compact" in PS: Political Science & Politics.)
So, Would It Be Better?
I think the simplest way to judge a voting system is to ask whose votes count. Under the current system, the honest answer is: some votes count a lot, most count very little, and which is which depends on an accident of where you live.
A national popular vote wouldn't be perfect. Recounts could get ugly, plurality winners are a real risk, and the legal fight could be long. But it would turn Linda and Marcus from spectators into players. It would push campaigns to talk to the whole country. And it might even take some of the politics out of disaster relief.
That seems like a good trade to me. But you don't have to agree. Here's the test I'd suggest: forget which party you think it helps this year. Parties change. Coalitions shift. Ask whether you'd want this system if you had no idea who'd win under it next time.
If your answer is yes, the compact is 48 votes away.